Fall is a time for renewal — of your DVR queue. But agreeing with your S.O. on which shows to watch can be challenging. Let editors (and soon-to-be-married couple) Brooke Siegel and Dan Murphy be your TV guides.Boardwalk EmpireMartin Scorsese produces (and directs the pilot of) the HBO show about Prohibition-era Atlantic City.She says: After the Mad Men-inspired fashion bonanza, I’m ready for the Roaring Twenties to hit the runway. And Steve Buscemi is always compelling.He says: A famous film auteur, gangsters, molls, booze, and a Sopranos-size void — what’s not to love?Premiere: HBO, September 19, 9 p.m. EST.Nikita The remake stars Maggie Q as a rogue spy trying to take down a secret government agency that trains assassins. She says: Last Thursday’s premiere showed promise, if only for the presence of hottie Shane West. Besides, I miss Alias. He says: My girlfriend misses Alias. [Ed note: Aw. Vomit.]Airs: The CW, Thursday, 9 p.m. EST (download the pilot on iTunes).The EventAll we know about the intentionally vague plot: It involves a life-altering, worldwide conspiracy. She says: I’m skeptical. Can it succeed where Lost failed? (Is it me, or does everyone have Jimmy Fallon’s Lost song stuck in her head?) He says: You win this time, ad wizards. Premiere: NBC, September 20, 9 p.m. EST.No Ordinary FamilyAfter a plane crash in the Amazon, a typical American family develops superpowers.She says: It’s everyone’s fantasy to wake up and discover he has supernatural abilities — just ask J.K. Rowling. He says: Do I think the holidays would be more fun if my dad could fly and my sister could pick up cars? Yes, I do.Premiere: ABC, September 28, 8 p.m. EST.The Walking DeadA group struggles to survive in a zombie-infested postapocalyptic world, written, directed, and produced by Frank Darabont (The Shawshank Redemption).She says: The undead are so hot right now.He says: Sure, it’s lowbrow territory. But if anyone can make zombies classy, it’s AMC.Premiere: AMC, October 31, 10 p.m. EST.Running WildeA morally bankrupt billionaire (Will Arnett) tries to win back his do-gooder childhood sweetheart. From Mitch Hurwitz, creator of Arrested Development.She says: Minus two points for the title. Plus a million points for the Arrested Development pedigree. He says: I worry the plot will go stale. But Mitch Hurwitz could write a Subaru commercial, and I’d TiVo it.Premiere: Fox, September 21, 9:30 p.m. EST.Photo: ThinkstockWhere do you fall on the fashion scale? Can you handle an exhibit-worthy Tom Scott? A fiercely stylish Albertus Swanepoel? Find out by sneaking a peek at our spring 2011 Fashion Week coverage.Up to 50% off DogearedBeautify yourself and the planet with the line’s handcrafted jewelry — engraved with words like fearless and peace — and organic cotton totes. Up to 50% off today on Swirl.