You would drive all the way to Ohio for Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams, but those artisanal pints are just as sweet and flavorful when ordered online. Present your pal with the opportunity to order brown butter almond brittle, salty caramel, honey vanilla, or a host of other flavors. Put the e-mail certificate in a cone.

Available at jenisicecreams.com, $25-$100.